Pictures of gear caught fish?

Discussion in 'Fly Fishing Forum' started by Clint F, Mar 2, 2009.

  1. Clint F Fly Fishing Youth

    Posts: 675
    Port Orchard,WA
    Ratings: +3 / 0
    Wow, I was not expecting this. I just asked what you all thought. I picked out one person that really got defensive and butthurt/other reasons as well, and they will not have to worry about going in my boat again. I just think if you have gear caught fish why post it on a fly fishing website? It doesnt make sense. It took me a while to get back to you guys because I was fishing earlier which I think some of you should have been doing as well.

    Clint
  2. Salmo_g Active Member

    Posts: 7,470
    Your City ,State
    Ratings: +1,610 / 0
    Chrome/22,

    Gear, obviously, but that's not the point nor the issue. And seriously, if I held that fish in my hands after landing it on a gear rod, I'd think long and hard about the wasted opportunity. But that's me. I don't expect you or anyone to understand, but there's no steelhead on this planet that I want to catch badly enough to use a gear rod to catch it. I choose to not catch a boatload of steelhead by deliberately choosing to fly fish for them. That's not to say I never fish with other gear, but it's for the distraction of a broader experience and making me a more complete angler and to catch other fish species, but not because I want to catch a mega-steelhead and post pictures of it.

    D3,

    7 pages of crap in your opinion. Personally I think the original poster asked a logical question. Why the hell would someone post photos of gear caught fish on a fly fishing forum? It makes about as much sense as me asking a treaty Indian friend to give me a photo of some gillnet caught steelhead so I can post them on this forum. Really, if choice of tackle doesn't matter, then why don't we all choose gillnets and really get 'er done? And don't underestimate the adrenaline rush of sport drift gillnetting.

    Jerry,

    So what is gear fishing? I think it's not the same for everyone. However, by any objective measure, it isn't near the challenge as fly fishing for winter steelhead simply because conventional spin and casting gear is an easier and more effective method for consistently catching more steelhead. I generally don't get too judgemental on forums, but anyone who doesn't understand the above statement flat out doesn't know all that much about steelheading.

    Sg
  3. 1morecast Active Member

    Posts: 745
    Port Angeles
    Ratings: +49 / 0
    Anil,

    Good for you for choosing to experiment. By experimenting is how I came to love fly fishing.

    I am going to have to disagree with you, I don't see the similarities between Centerpin and fly fishing tackle. The methods used with both tackle are close. And if more and more fly fisherman are using centerpin outfits are they still fly fishing?

    With all the differant opinons on here I wonder, how many anglers started out fishing with gear and moved to fly fishing only, and how many started out fly fishing and have moved or started to use other gear.

    Personally I could care less how a person chooses to fish. The point of this post is this is a FLY FISHING SITE!!
  4. Hooker Banned or Parked

    Posts: 273
    WA
    Ratings: +0 / 0
    do you look at a picture of a fish to see the rod it was caught on or to see the beauty of the fish?
  5. Hooker Banned or Parked

    Posts: 273
    WA
    Ratings: +0 / 0


    please explain the subtle different between an egg sucking leech with weighted head and a jig? or the difference between an indicator(such as a thing-a-ma-bobber) and a float.


    i dont care how people fish and i dont look at pictures other than to see the individual fish. I am impressed more by fly caught than gear caught fish, but i still find beauty in the fish regardless.. in fact i see more pictures of nasty fly caught fish than i do nasty gear caught fish.
    It may be a fly fishing forum but with all the other bullshit that gets posted on here do we really want to start regulating it down so that every little bit of info, story, picture has to be 100% fly fishing? to me that would be boring. if you dont like it, dont look.
  6. cuponoodle breakfast gritty

    Posts: 1,650
    Arlington
    Ratings: +303 / 0
    True. Maybe your avatar would be more appropriate on HawaiiFlyfishing.com? :)
  7. GATOR9 Hey you guys

    Posts: 608
    Yakima, Wa.
    Ratings: +18 / 0
    I enjoy a good discussion and a funny one even more but if this thing goes any further with its context do so on the Drakemag. Enough is enough!
  8. HauntedByWaters Active Member

    Posts: 2,746
    Bellingham
    Ratings: +103 / 0
    There isn't any. My point was that there is no difference between indicator/nymph fishing and jig/float fishing. Both are the same in essence. Neither is fly fishing IMO.

    When people describe getting a winter steelhead on the fly as an accomplishment, they are talking about using a swung fly. Other methods are fine, obviously, just not even close to as difficult to achieve.

    The reason this is pertinent is that fly fishing is essentially a self imposed handicap. It is fun to cast and everything, but from a catching standpoint it is a handicap and uses a style of fishing developed well over a hundred years ago.

    If you are basically catching a jig/float fish on a fly rod, than you are not doing what these old timers and swingers are so addicted to. The reason there are books written about the PNW and its steelhead fly fishing is because of the opportunity to get them on a swung fly, not to simly get a steelhead with whatever method is available. If you simply want to hook a steelhead, that is a more gear oriented approach, which is fine, just not the same.

    Dude.....what is with people taking this shit so personal?

    Nobody here is telling anybody how to fish. Nobody cares how anybody else fishes. There were a few elitist posts here but mostly this conversation is about what is and isn't fly fishing.

    If you don't care about what is and isn't fly fishing that is fine, you just have to realize that fly fishing definately is something else, and a lot of people are deeply in love with it and constantly ponder what is and isn't fly fishing.

    Have you never wondered about what makes fly fishing fly fishing?

    It is the self imposed choice to use an older simpler style of fishing while sacrificing catch rate. It is not simply about having a fly rod in hand and casting whatever you attach to your line with it.

    If you think all this talk about fishing is bullshit than you have no idea how crazy into this some people are like me.

    People have been discussing the virtues of fly versus bait for hundreds of years. It is a never ending discussion and some of us love it. The reason I hang out here is to have, hopefully, civil discussion about all these things with others and recieve fresh perspective. We aren't trying to impose our views on others. Life is about the quest of knowledge and understanding of self. I do that through fishing, many of us do that through fly fishing specifically.

    Those of you that read all these posts and see it as an argument need to see it as a bunch of guys bullshitting about fishing and philosophy. There aren't any personal attacks going on. If you can't chat with civility amongst people who you disagree with than you are a coward.
  9. longstick Member

    Posts: 280
    North West
    Ratings: +0 / 0
    Coach, if you liked to swing so much why did you move? And all the posts of your bone fish and your company stuff on a washington site. I run a guide service too, yes I have a link to my site and have chimed in a few times about alaska but I don't post about my stuff in ak all the time. Hawaii to the Northwest is like gear to flyfishing.

    Whats really funny is how Washingtons love to spey fish and 10 or more years ago many talked shit about it. Centerpins are hated now but you mark my words that in 5-10 years many on this and other sites will be doing it. Not all the time but when it is necessary.

    I love Hawaii, bone fishing, spey fishing steelheading, centerpinning, and gear fishing with clients.

    As far as a 20 pound fish held out of water with water running off it, take more photos that way, also I know of a 20 pounder that was a unclip hatchery fish that had a wore dorsile fin and people who saw the picture called in the holder. Fuck Off he released a huge hatchery fish and was in 10 inches of water with the fish just above it.

    For me I hate seeing guys holding trout and Steelhead that are about to be released with fleece or wool gloves on. Might as well bonk that fish. And fish with there head dragged out of water half way on the bank with a spey fly in its mouth.

    Come on guys lets all get a drink and fish. Yes this is a fly site so note to those that want to show a gear caught fish...... take the hook out and remove the rod from the photo. They won't know the difference.
  10. Coach Duff Banned or Parked

    Posts: 1,272
    Kailua Hawaii
    Ratings: +6 / 0
    One a steelheader, always a Washington born and raised steelheader. The avatar may change once in a while as the zip code but my heart has and never will leave the rivers and steelhead of home. And giant bonefish are one hell of a consolation prize Cupper!:beer2: Coach
  11. Coach Duff Banned or Parked

    Posts: 1,272
    Kailua Hawaii
    Ratings: +6 / 0
    First off, why the defensive "guilty as hell" posture?
    Why did I move? I was a college football coach. I also coached in Arizona and Utah and posted from there too. My home is Washington and always will be. My last season was 2007 when UH went to the Sugar Bowl. I had an opportunity to go to SMU with June but wanted my children to be raised in Hawaii, where my wife is from. Now that you know why, who cares. I swing the fly because I was raised in Washington where many of the rivers swing the fly very well. Probably about the same time you were introduced to Alaska's prolific "Glo Bug Hatch", a bunch of Northwest guys realized the advantages of using spey rods in these same waters to increase their fly drift and to cover water un reacheable due to backcast issues or just the massive size involved. You can call me or any number of members of this site if you want the history rundown.;) In fact 10 years ago, we were alreay 10 solid years into spey rods in Washington in earnest. This is a fly site. And loving Hawaii centerpins, lead tossing and egg patterns has nothing to do with this post, with pictures of gear caught steelhead or with me. I post on here all the time because I know a bunch of guys on this site and spent a long time steelheading in Washington. Fishing is fishing, and I think it is all great, but I am sure you can find a forum for centrepins, gear fishing, Alaskan "flyfishing" and maybe even Hawaiian Bonefishing. Scoones, IBN and the rest of the leadership here have always kept me honest and if I get too commercial they slap me in the head. Really that's none of your business either. After all you found WASHINGTON FLYFISHING now didn't you? It should be easy for you to find the other sites!!! Tight lines and watch out, your "impenetrable" fish runs up there are starting to dwindle. The only shit talking I've heard for the last 25 years was you folks telling us how shitty our fisheries management was as you yucked it up and raked salmon across the back. It's starting to get quiet up there............

    PS It's okay I truly believe that in every gear fisherman is a fly angler screaming to get out. And if you keep working at it, eventually you'll have enough confidence in your teaching and guiding abilities to only fish the fly with clients. Of course you'll have to stop counting fish on the clicker you carry in your pocket and on long tough days have to interact with then on a human level, but it will all come in due time. Much mahalos Coach
  12. Hooker Banned or Parked

    Posts: 273
    WA
    Ratings: +0 / 0
    obviously fanatical about fishing, obviously not much on the comprehensive reading. :beathead:
    to each their own. :thumb:
  13. gearhead Active Member

    Posts: 661
    Renton, wa
    Ratings: +45 / 0
    Lol, Is it wrong for me to say i love flyfishing, but i can't stand flyfishermen.

    i love the openness and inclusive nature of so many of the ass's on this board, a board i love by the way.
  14. GATOR9 Hey you guys

    Posts: 608
    Yakima, Wa.
    Ratings: +18 / 0
    "I love fly fising but I can't stand fly fisherman"

    Now that is good. I really like that one.

    I'm sure one of the reasons that I got into fly fishing had something to do with "anger mgt."

    I must of have been wrong. Why would anyone that lives on the island be so angry?
  15. Gary Thompson dirty dog

    Posts: 3,891
    East Wenatchee, WA
    Ratings: +131 / 0
    I can't believe I read the whole thing.
    Maybe I'll get the last word in.
    When I grew up in southern Oregon on the Rogue and Applegate rivers nothing made me feel better than drifting a fat nite crawler through a deep hole and hooking and landing a fat wild steelhead, meat on the table.
    Well that was 35+ years ago and I will never go back to bait or spin to fish for steelhead, swing fly or nothing.
    Now if ya want to post a gear caught fish on this forum, that's your business. But I joined to see fly caught fish and talk about fly fishing.
    Peace and love brothers. Dirty Dog out
  16. HauntedByWaters Active Member

    Posts: 2,746
    Bellingham
    Ratings: +103 / 0
    You can say whatever you want! :thumb:
  17. Jake Bannon nymphs for steelhead....

    Posts: 667
    puget sound
    Ratings: +0 / 0

    Best damn post in the entire thread.
  18. Clint F Fly Fishing Youth

    Posts: 675
    Port Orchard,WA
    Ratings: +3 / 0
    PS It's okay I truly believe that in every gear fisherman is a fly angler screaming to get out. And if you keep working at it, eventually you'll have enough confidence in your teaching and guiding abilities to only fish the fly with clients. Of course you'll have to stop counting fish on the clicker you carry in your pocket and on long tough days have to interact with then on a human level, but it will all come in due time. Much mahalos Coach[/QUOTE]

    I have to agree. It is like puberty, some reach it faster than others and some never see the day. As some of you know I am 17, I have now reached a point where I will never allow another gear rod in my boats again. I want to thank everyone for their input. Some have pissed me off more but thats the way life goes. If anyone else has more comments I would love to hear them.

    Clint
  19. HauntedByWaters Active Member

    Posts: 2,746
    Bellingham
    Ratings: +103 / 0
    It would have been the best post if we were debating whether or not a gear caught steelhead is uglier than a fly caught steelhead but we aren't.
  20. Stonefish Triploid and Humpy Hater

    Posts: 3,862
    Pipers Creek
    Ratings: +1,260 / 1
    Your buddy calls. He offers you a seat to float some OP rivers. He shows up at your house. He has both fly and gear rods in his boat. Do you turn down the invite because of your feelings on gear rods or go because gear rods are ok, just not on your boat?