Switch or Spey?

Discussion in 'Spey Clave' started by lando, Jun 25, 2013.

  1. lando

    lando Member

    On a recent trip to Pyramid Lake, an old baseball elbow injury reemerged after casting a shooting head with my 8 weight for 4 days. More than two months later, my elbow is still giving me problems so I've been thinking of buying my first two-handed rod. The problem is that I have no experience with such rods and don't know where to begin.

    I would use it at Pyramid Lake twice a year with a fast sinking tip to hopefully increase my casting distance and save my elbow and for the occasional steelhead/salmon trip to the PNW. I'm leaning toward a 7 weight or 6/7 weight. Looking at a TCX or TFO Deer Creek and would also consider Echo. But first need to determine whether a switch or spey rod would be best for my intended use? Any advice appreciated.
     
  2. I would say spey for learning but if you know what your doing then go with a switch. I started with a 7 wt switch rod, and had lots of trouble, then bought an 8wt 13'6 echo tr and things started to click. That 7wt now is substantially easier than before because the spey is a little more forgiving in my opinion when your learning
     
  3. Steve Saville

    Steve Saville Active Member

    Huge difference between a Deer Creek and a TCX. I've owned both. The TCX is much faster. The Deer Creek is a lot more forgiving but I sold both that I had and replaced them with TCX's.
     
  4. steve s

    steve s Member

    Are you planning on using the rod for spey type casts or overhead casts at Pyramid Lake? For spey casts, I would suggest a spey rod for some of the reasons that Bass stated above. Although some of the newer switch rods are in the 11.5' length and shouldn't be too difficult to learn. If you plan on doing overhead/two handed casting, I would suggest a switch. The lines you choose will depend on the type of casting and flies that you want to throw. From the choices that you mentioned, I would go for the TCX. They're great rods and you can get a great deal right now on closeout. If you plan on using your rod for steelheading, specifically winter steelheading, I would go for a 7 weight.
     
  5. docstash

    docstash Member

    I would go with a switch overhead casting in a 6wt over head or even a 5wt if you want to match the single handed 8wt. Two handed rods are 2-3 lines over equivalent single handers when you are talking about TCX or One. TCX at 11' 9" is very close to a full spey and lighter and faster than most switch rods out there. Shoot us an email at Reds and lets see if we have some TCX in stock that are discontinued. We always set up custom packages at Reds at great prices.

    craig@redsflyshop.com
     
  6. Chris Johnson

    Chris Johnson Member: Native Fish Society

  7. cmann886

    cmann886 Active Member

    I would give Craig from Reds a call. He helped to set me up with the right line for a 5 wt. switch rod which is now my favorite. The rod when correctly matched to the line was unbelievable. My 7 wt. is just alot heavier and doen't realy put out any more line that the 5 wt. now that it is correctly matched. The new Redington prospector is a very nice rod if you are not persuaded by the TCX. For what you described the 5 wt. would probably do what you needed unless you plan some big river fishing for winter steel.
     
  8. Ed Call

    Ed Call Mumbling Moderator Staff Member

    Switch for that two handed water haul and launch cast. Super short extreme weight forward line will deliver the goods with minimal effort. Docstash speaks solid logic.
     
  9. lando

    lando Member

    Well now I'm wondering if I made a mistake. After receiving the first few comments, I found a deal on a TCX 7126-4 and bought it. Will I be overgunned at Pyramid with it..the winds are pretty gnarly there? I could possibly return the rod and buy a 6 weight switch. Your thoughts?
     
  10. get the 6 wt too;)


    that way you wont be out gunned or have brought a cannon to a butter knife fight
     
  11. lando

    lando Member

    Unfortunately, I only have a 1 rod budget right now.
     
  12. miyawaki

    miyawaki Active Member

    Are you guys all recommending that he speycast twohanders on stillwater into the wind? Are your sure this will be the cure for a bad elbow?

    Leland.
     
    underachiever likes this.
  13. Luke77

    Luke77 I hope she likes whitefish

    Overhead cast the switch rod on the lake.
    If you plan on steelheading with the same rod, get the 6 wt.
    I use my 6 wt switch for trout and steel and have had NO issues with steelhead.
     
  14. James Waggoner

    James Waggoner Active Member

    Doesn't sound like you'll get much on the water practice if you only intend to fish a handful of time as year...learning to two hand cast takes time and commitment. Without those two you will be very frustrated. The best advice would be to seek treatment for your elbow or learn to cast with the other arm.

    I actually don't mind complaining about my shoulder hurting after a week of hard fishing...just wish it happened more.
     
    BASS_TURDS likes this.
  15. Sunray shadow

    Sunray shadow New Member

    if you wanna get rid of the 7126 let me know I have a bnit Buelah 11 for 7 switch platinum maybe we could do a trade plus cash
     
  16. hydrological

    hydrological beads are NOT flies and snagging is just ghetto

    X 1,000 the switch will be an easy transition later, and the long rod 12.5-13.5' will be great for deep wading. for those fic=sh you guys have a 7wt wouldnt be overkill either.